On a Port Talbot roof the important cost question is not what a repair costs. It is whether that repair will still be holding in two winters, because a patch on a roof with corroded fixings is a job you will be paying for again.
Sites publishing an average cost for a storm damage repair are publishing a number that describes nothing: the same phrase covers replacing two tiles on a bungalow and rebuilding a chimney on a three-storey property. What is useful is knowing what moves the number, so you can judge a quotation on its merits.
This is the decision that matters here, and it is worth understanding before anybody quotes, because two roofers can give you very different prices and both be honest.
Salt-laden air corrodes the nails, clips and straps holding a roof covering on. When a storm takes tiles off a coastal roof, one of two things has happened. Either the wind exceeded what sound fixings could hold — in which case the fixings either side are fine and a patch is the right answer. Or the fixings had already gone and the wind simply found them — in which case the tiles either side of your new patch are hanging on the same corroded nails.
Replace what is missing, re-secure the immediate area. Quick, much cheaper, and completely correct where the surrounding fixings have life in them.
Address the fixings across the affected slope rather than only at the gap. Considerably more expensive, and the difference between solving it and postponing it where corrosion is general.
Ask this question directly, and expect a reason for the answer. “Are the fixings around this area sound, or is the same thing about to happen either side of the repair?” Somebody who has actually looked will have a view and be able to say why. A quotation that does not engage with it leaves you to find out over the next two winters, and by then you have paid for the access twice.
The arithmetic is worth doing plainly. Access is a large part of the cost of any roof repair, and you pay it every single time somebody comes out. Three patches over three winters means three lots of access. That is how a sequence of cheap repairs quietly becomes more expensive than doing it properly once.
Access is the single biggest cost driver on any roof repair, and Port Talbot varies enormously.
If two quotations differ substantially, access is the first place to look. One may have priced scaffolding and the other a ladder, which is a difference in what is being proposed rather than in price.
One thing worth refusing at any price. Flashing repaired with mastic or roofing cement instead of properly dressed lead is cheaper on the day and cracks within a few years, because it sets rigid while the roof and the masonry move at different rates and temperatures.
On a coastal roof it fails faster still. If a quotation is markedly cheaper than the others and involves flashing, it is worth asking specifically what material is being used.
Worth raising because it affects the total and because homeowners are often surprised to see it on a storm damage quotation at all.
Wind-blown sand and salt work hardest on the roofline — the guttering, fascia and soffit along the eaves — because those are coated components on the most exposed line of the building. Once the finish has been scoured off, they deteriorate faster than the roof covering above them, and a storm that takes tiles off will frequently have finished off guttering that was already most of the way there.
The practical point is about access rather than opportunism. If scaffolding or a tower is going up for the roof repair anyway, roofline work done at the same time costs a fraction of what it costs as a separate visit later, because you are not paying for the access twice. It is worth asking whether anything at that level needs doing while somebody is up there — and equally worth expecting a straight answer if the honest one is no.
T & T Roofing South Wales quotes free and without obligation across Port Talbot and Sandfields. If the roof does not need the work, that is what we will tell you.
Because salt air corrodes the fixings across the whole slope, not just where the tiles came off. If corrosion is general, the tiles either side of a patch are held by the same weakened nails.
The strongest clue is what came down. Whole, undamaged material with clean fixing holes points at failed fixings. Ask the roofer directly whether the surrounding fixings are sound, and expect a reason.
It depends entirely on the condition of the fixings. Where they are sound, no — a patch is right and cheaper. Where corrosion is general, three patches over three winters means paying for access three times.
Ask what material is being used. Mastic or roofing cement instead of properly dressed lead is cheaper on the day and cracks within a few years, and faster than that on a coastal roof.
Storm damage in Port Talbot? T & T Roofing South Wales will assess the roof, explain what needs repairing and give you a free, no-obligation quotation. Storm Damage Roof Repairs Port Talbot has the full detail, or call us on 07766 547309.
Tell us what the weather has done and what you can see from the ground. We will come back to you — usually the same day.
If water is coming in now, please call rather than email — 07766 547309.